Tenant screening is the most important thing you do as a landlord. The right tenant pays rent on time, keeps the property in good shape, and renews. The wrong one costs you lost rent, property damage, legal fees, and months of your life. Here is what to check before you hand over the keys.
Why Screening Matters More Than You Think
A bad tenant is not just inconvenient. The financial damage adds up quickly. Lost rent during an eviction process can run three to six months in many states. Property damage beyond normal wear and tear often exceeds the security deposit. Legal costs for an eviction proceeding range from $1,500 to $5,000 or more depending on your state.
There is also an insurance angle. Insurance claims follow the property. If a tenant causes a fire, a flood, or repeated liability incidents, your claims history goes up. That raises your premium at renewal and can make you harder to insure. Screening well reduces claims. Fewer claims keep your insurance costs manageable.
The Five Things to Check
1. Credit score. A credit score of 620 or above is a reasonable starting point for most landlords. It shows the applicant pays their obligations. A score below 600 does not automatically disqualify someone, but it should prompt more questions. Look at the pattern: is it a brief rough patch or a long history of non-payment? Context matters.
2. Income. The standard rule of thumb is that the tenant's gross monthly income should be at least three times the monthly rent. If rent is $1,800, you want to see at least $5,400 per month in verifiable gross income. Ask for recent pay stubs, tax returns for self-employed applicants, or bank statements showing consistent deposits.
3. Rental history. Call previous landlords. Not just the current one, who may be trying to get rid of a problem tenant. Ask about payment history, property condition at move-out, any lease violations, and whether they would rent to the person again. A landlord who hesitates or gives vague answers is a signal worth taking seriously.
4. Criminal background. Run a background check. You are allowed to consider criminal history in tenant screening, but you must apply your standards consistently to all applicants. Be aware of local rules. Some cities and states restrict how landlords can use criminal records in housing decisions.
5. References. Personal references matter less than landlord and employer references. Anyone can provide three friends who will vouch for them. Ask for an employer contact to verify employment and a prior landlord who is not the current one.
Fair Housing Rules: What You Cannot Do
Federal fair housing law prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and disability. Many states and cities add additional protected classes including source of income, sexual orientation, and marital status.
You cannot ask about these protected categories. You cannot set different standards for different applicants based on them. You can set any criteria you want, including minimum income, minimum credit score, and no-pets policy, as long as you apply them consistently to every applicant.
Document your criteria in writing before you advertise. Apply them the same way every time. Keep records of every applicant and why they were approved or denied.
Require Renters Insurance
Make renters insurance a condition of tenancy. It is inexpensive for the tenant, roughly $15 to $30 per month, and it protects both of you. If a tenant accidentally causes a fire or floods a neighboring unit, their renters insurance covers their liability. Without it, you may be dealing with a damaged property and a tenant who cannot pay for it.
Ask for proof of coverage before move-in and at each renewal. Some landlords ask to be listed as an interested party on the policy so they receive notice if it lapses.
The Connection Between Screening and Insurance Costs
Landlords with clean claims histories get better rates. Landlords with frequent claims get higher premiums or lose coverage entirely. A tenant who causes a fire, floods a unit, or triggers a liability claim goes into your insurance record, not theirs. Screening well is one of the most effective things you can do to keep your insurance costs in line over time.
Bottom Line
Check credit, income, rental history, criminal background, and references. Apply your standards consistently. Require renters insurance. Keep records. A 30-minute screening process can prevent a problem that takes months to resolve.
Want to know if your coverage fits your situation?
Start here: investorpropertyinsurance.com/get-a-quote